Rudiments of Rouge: Choosing the Right Shade of Blush For You

Rudiments of Rouge

Welcome to the 2nd episode of the mini series of the week, Rudiments of Rouge. I hope you enjoyed my short introduction and a bit of history of blush yesterday. I could have gone on and on about the toxic (and quite gory) methods of how ladies used to apply rouge on their cheeks but I thought, it was Monday; let’s keep it light! 🙂

Shopping for Blush

Today, I’m going to be talking about choosing the right shade of blush for you. I often get these questions from readers: what’s the best shade of blush for my skin? What’s the right colour for me? How can I apply it without looking like a doll? So I thought I’d tackle the first part of those questions today and it’s about selecting the right shade of blush for you.

You may have heard/read a lot about skin tones. Some say that warm-toned colours should stick to warm skin tones. Cool-toned colours go very well with cool skin tones. Neutral skin tone? Well, aren’t you lucky. 🙂

Warm Tones, Cool Tones

Well technically, they aren’t wrong. Warm-toned shades and warm skin tones complement each other well. The same goes for cool skin tones. Then again, I’m not a believer of warm-toned blush suiting only warm skin tones and cool-toned ones will only for cool skin tones. I believe you can cross that warm/cool toned ideal with blush.

Having said that, I won’t deny that a lot of the time, warm-toned colours like coral and peach do look better on warmer skin tones and cool-toned shades like pink, mauve, etc look better on cooler skin tones. The shades and tones work better together. On the other hand, I also believe that if the blush looks good on you, who cares if the colour tones don’t match?

Try it out first!

The best way – in fact, the only way – to know if a particular blush works for you is to TRY IT OUT. If possible, try it out on your cheeks. I don’t recommend determining if the blush will look good on your based on just a swipe of colour on the back of your hand. Your hands have more noticeable veins that your cheeks don’t have. These veins enhance the warmth or cool of the skin. Or you might have some redness on your cheeks that the back of your hand doesn’t have. Either way, it’s not a good place to judge if the colour is good. It may be okay if the blush is a cheapie but what if it’s an expensive brand? You’ll want to know that it looks the best that it can on you before you hand over your hard-earned coin.

Rudiments of Rouge: Choosing the Right Shade of Blush For You

For example, let’s talk about NARS. You’ve read the reviews and they aren’t exaggerated. Their blushes are good. Anyway, years ago, I bought the lipstick in Dolce Vita. It’s a beautiful colour of dusky mauve that looked great on me. When I saw the blush, I tried it out on the back of my hand and it looked good. I snapped it up, brought it home and tried it out on my cheeks the next day. Oh dear, it didn’t look as good as I originally thought it did. On the back of my hand, it looked pretty. However, on my cheeks, it just looked dirty. The colour didn’t complement my skin tone at all. In the end, I had to give it away. Moral of the story is, whenever possible and especially when you’re buying an expensive blush, try it out on your cheeks first.

Should I get that super-duper popular blush?

What about cult blushes? Surely they’re a must have. If beauty blogs and magazines say that they’re good, surely I should add them to my collection! One of the cult blushes stated as a must-have would be the very popular NARS Orgasm (when it comes to blush, I do tend to talk a lot about NARS :P). Beauty editors claim that it’s a universal shade that suits all so this must suit me too. Unfortunately, it did not. It didn’t look on me as well as I expected it to. It was too light and shimmery for my liking. In the end, I gave mine away to Beetrice.

Another moral of the story is: only trust your eyes and your face. By all means, please try these popular blushes first before plonking down your money. It may not look as good as you think it would just because you read it in a magazine (or see me recommend it on Beautyholics Anonymous!). If it doesn’t work for you, move on to something else. You don’t have to get it simply because it’s deemed a MUST-HAVE. If it doesn’t work for you, it’s just a waste of money.

Rudiments of Rouge: Choosing the Right Shade of Blush For You

Let’s go back to skin tones. If you have warm skin tone like I do, don’t just stick to corals and peaches. I wouldn’t say go for the next bright pink you see but if you’re not sure, start out slow by trying a shade of dusky rose e.g. Chanel Blush Duo Tweed Effect in Tweed Rose. If that works, go for something with more pink in it. Once you’re more comfortable with these cool-toned shades, then go for something more punchy like berry or mauve. Having, for example, Ben Nye’s Fuchsia as your first blush will probably freak you out :P. The same goes for cool-toned skin. Don’t immediately go for bright corals like NARS’ Exhibit A or Sunday Riley’s Rush if you’re unsure. Start slow with a peachy-pink first like Benefit’s Bella Bamba.

Rudiments of Rouge: Choosing the Right Shade of Blush For You

Matte vs shimmer

Next, matte or shimmer? This boils down to personal preference. Blushes with some shimmer in them gives the cheeks a lovely glow, especially on the top of the cheeks where it gets the most light. Matte blushes gives the effect of smoothness on the cheeks. I like a mixture of both. I’m not a fan of very shimmery blushes because I cannot control the amount of shimmer I want. I’d rather have something with a lot less shimmer and if I want more glowy goodness on my skin, I’ll do a light sweep of the Guerlain Meteorites all over my face.

Rudiments of Rouge: Choosing the Right Shade of Blush For You

So, after rambling on for, hmm, 10 paragraphs, my point is: the best way to decide if a blush shade or style works for you is to try it out first. This may not always be possible when shopping at drugstores so what I like to do is

  1. Use a clean tissue to wipe across the tester blush powder and remove the top layer. Always assume testers aren’t clean. The tissue is to remove the remnants of touch from the last person who has touched it.
  2. With a clean finger, swatch the product at the back of my hand and pat a little of the blush on my cheek.

This isn’t the best method but it’s one to try if you’d like to try drugstore makeup on yourself. For mid-range to high-end makeup that are more expensive, I have the available makeup artist or sales assistant try it on me.

Don’t be afraid to test out bright blushes because sometimes they may look crazy bright on the palette but when you try it out, they may be quite sheer. I’ll say it again: experiment, experiment, experiment!

Have fun choosing blushes! 😀

Do you select blushes based on your skin tone or just get what looks good on you?

Stay tuned to the next Rudiments of Rouge episode where I talk about powder vs cream blushes!

For weekly updates, news and heaps more fun stuff, do subscribe and join the awesome BA Insider community!

Join the BA Insider Community

Previous:

Next:

27 comments… add one
  1. Tegan @ Tegania's Thoughts

    haha I love your rambling 😉 I too have falled prey to the ‘must have’ blush, and now many a blush sit in my makeup drawer, while I use my MAC one that was colour matched for me every single day (and have done, for like the past seven years). Le sigh haha
    Tegan @ Tegania’s Thoughts recently posted..MAC Lipstick in Girl About Town {Swatch}My Profile

    1. Tine

      Haha so glad I have someone liking my rambling 😛 I too have a lot of blushes sitting pretty but quite useless in my makeup drawers. In hindsight, what a waste of money they were but when I got them, they were so highly raved. Problem is I bought a lot of them before even trying them on (all no thanks to online shopping!). See, I don’t practice what I preach up there 😛

  2. LeGeeque

    Thanks for the informative post 😀 Trust you to do the hard work in researching this 🙂

    1. Tine

      Haha thanks! Mostly written while lunching at Bouchée 😉

  3. Jenn

    What an awesome post. I had to stop and ogle at all that beautiful blushes!! 😀 😀

    I agree with you – we all have to be careful to not buy into the “universally flattering” nonsense. NARS Orgasm didn’t work for me too 🙁
    Jenn recently posted..Product Review: Estee Lauder Advanced Night Repair Synchronized Recovery ComplexMy Profile

    1. Tine

      Thanks Jenn and happy ogling! More to come 😉

      To me, the words “universally flattering” are synonymous to “free size” for clothes. No. Such. Thing.

  4. Sunshine

    Hi Tine! I’m loving these blog posts about blush. I am definitely a newbie when it comes to blush, but I found that trying out the blush shade is the only way to really know how it will look on the skin. Great post and I’m looking forward to the rest of the blush posts for this week. xo Sunshine.

    1. Tine

      Thanks Sunshine! Love your name, btw. Puts a smile on my face 🙂

      Have fun shopping for blush. It’s my favourite thing to shop for!

  5. Norlin

    Oh wow! Who knew there was so much to write about blush!! Well, honestly? I choose blush according to what I see. Yeah, not very scientific I know. I’ve got a fair share of warm and cool tones…not that I care really. If it looks good I pick it up…and yeah…without testing too! LOL!
    Norlin recently posted..How To Survive A Big Night Out When You’re Over 30My Profile

    1. Tine

      Hahahaha just like I had no idea there’s so much one can talk about lipstick! Tell the men; see, it’s not as easy as you think. Makeup can be very complicated! 😛

      A lot of blushes I have are purchased without even trying them on. I know! Talk about not practicing what I preach :P. They were purchased online, so can’t try them on but only rely on swatches done by other bloggers 😛

  6. Allison

    This morning I put on Physicians Formula blush with the hearts in the peachy shades, generally a good selection of tones for me. There is however one dark peach/orange-ish heart in the mix that always manages not to blend on my blush. I was in a hurry trying to get ready to catch the train. Of course, I ended up with a dark peach/orange spot on both cheeks that just didn’t want to blend. I got out a tissue and tried to scrape it off. Any ideas on how to blend multi-toned blush palettes, or on how to remove blush mistakes?
    Allison recently posted..Obsessive Compulsive Lip TarMy Profile

    1. Tine

      Good question Allison! For me, I blend multi-toned blushes with a larger fluffy brush. I prefer not to use smaller blush brushes (with very packed and stiff bristles) because they tend to only pick up certain shades if you don’t run your brush all over the palette. But if you don’t want to get a specific brush for that (don’t waste your money if it isn’t something you need), then make sure you swipe your brush all over the palette. I have a similar Physicians Formula blush and have to make sure I run my brush over the entire blush a few times to make sure I get a combination of colours and not just concentrated pink or too much shimmer.as

      As for removing blush mistakes, stay tuned to my next couple of posts as I’ll be writing on that too 🙂

  7. Victoria

    Thanks for this post. It is really informative and a good guide for newbies. I recently bought Estee Lauder Pure Colour Blush in Pink Kiss. I tested the blush on my cheeks and it looked really nice and I bought it. The next day when I tried the blush to work, I found I needed 6-8 swipes of my Lunasol Cheek Brush to get the colour to show up on my skin. So I am not sure if it is because of the brush, the fact that the blush is a bit hard or the colour may not suit my NC 42 skin tone. I read the reviews that the blush is actually quite pigmented so the brush should not be the problem.

    My mom who is a lot fairer than me has Witty Peach from the same range and she also found that she needed a few swipes for the blush to show up on her skin. She uses the brush applicator provided with the blush. So I am guessing it is the blush itself? Just a bit puzzle as most of the reviews said that this blush is very pigmented and should have no issues showing up on skin with 2 swipes…

    1. Tine

      Hi Victoria,
      Hmm it could be the blushes themselves but I can’t tell because I don’t have that blush. I’ll go test it out at an Estée Lauder counter and let you know what I think. For now, try swirling the blush harder, tap off excess and try it again?

      1. Victoria

        Hi Tine. I decided to follow your advice and swirl by blush brush in the pan and it worked! I guess for this blush, I have to use this method and cannot just swipe my brush on the pan. Thanks for the advice 🙂

        1. Tine

          Yay! So glad it works! 😀

  8. Barbara

    Great post, so informative! One of my favorite ways to test a new blush is by applying it to a cosmetic wedge and holding the wedge up to my cheek. You can compare two colors at a time and find one most suitable before commiting to trying it on 🙂
    Barbara recently posted..The Body Shop Vineyard Peach Body ButterMy Profile

    1. Tine

      What a very clever idea, Barbara! Thanks for the tip! 😀

  9. gio

    What a great post! I choose blushes that look good on me. Doesn’t matter how pretty or popular something is, if it doesn’t look good on you, you’re just throwing money away.
    gio recently posted..Product Review: Haus Of Gloi Honey Tree Pumpkin ButterMy Profile

    1. Tine

      Thanks Gio. I agree; it doesn’t matter how popular and MUST-HAVE those cult blushes are. If they don’t look good on you, they’re not worth the money you spend.

  10. Efrain

    I think you’re right the best it’s trying on. For example in my tanned skin many brownish shades look muddy so I go for the bright ones.
    Efrain recently posted..De cómo llegué al mundo de la cosméticaMy Profile

    1. Tine

      Which are your favourites?

      1. Efrain

        Well in fact I have only two: Benetint (it’s a rosy red) and one eyeshadow from a Mexican Brand called Bissu (a matte bright pink), but the last one I ended mixing it with the bronzer that comes in Sleek’s face form palette; for mixing I mean grind both powders, mix them and add alcohol to make them pressed again. Now I have a custom shade.

        I don’t like brownish shades because I have golden undertones so the yellow in my skin mixes with the brown and look muddy for example Mac Harmony. I rather go for reds, bright pinks and corals. I have in mind to splurge in Exhibit A.

        1. Tine

          The Exhibit A is GORGEOUS. I think you’ll love it!

  11. En En

    Haha to be honest, I don’t have the slightest idea what is my skin tone or shades but I typically buy blushers in 2 shades: one pinkish/rosy shade, one coral/orangey shade and I come to notice that my face ‘absorbs’ the latter better with typical just 2 swipes for powder or few dabs for cream. My face doesn’t really ‘absorb’ pink/rosy that well. I usually have to double the swipes/dabs for pink on my face before the colour is obvious enough on my face.
    En En recently posted..It’s My 30th Year on EarthMy Profile

    1. Tine

      Hahaha yep that’s about right. You don’t have to stick to the rule of warm skin tones sticking to warm tones (vice versa for cool tones). You’ll notice which ones tend to look better on you. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Share your latest blog post with us!

Scroll To Top

Not another bloody pop-up! I know. But now that I've gotten your attention (because this is how I roll *ahem ahem*), come join the BA Insider community! Sign up for a weekly newsy letter for your beauty and lifestyle fix. Straight to your inbox.

Because I love you for reading this and not closing the pop-up just yet, you'll also receive a FREE Skincare Cheat Sheet where I share some of my tips for taking better care of your skin. Let's keep that gorgeous mug of yours glowing!

We hate spam as much as baked beans. We also won't share your details with anyone because we're selfish like that.